http://www.nytimes.com/2001/07/24/business/24FED.html

July 24, 2001

The Federal Reserve Finds the Limits of Its Power

By RICHARD W. STEVENSON

WASHINGTON, July 23  Despite six interest rate cuts by the Federal Reserve this year and the possibility of more to come, analysts say that monetary policy is packing less of a punch so far than expected.

The Fed's rate reductions work to the degree that they ripple through the banking system and the financial markets into the economy. And in this business cycle the three main vehicles through which lower rates affect business, investor and consumer behavior  the stock, bond and currency markets  have remained persistently unresponsive to the Fed's actions.

All year long, economists have predicted that the central bank's rate cuts would ultimately kick in with something like their usual force, stimulating a recovery from the economic slowdown. But one factor after another has conspired to dampen or delay the effects of the looser monetary policy on the markets and the economy.

"Monetary policy has a major problem in reviving the economy by itself in the year ahead," said David Hale, chief economist for the Zurich Group. "The best the Fed can do for us is a modest growth rate. To do better, the technology recession has got to end."

Disappointing corporate earnings reports have kept stock prices in check all year, and only seem to have grown worse in recent weeks. Worries that inflation might make a comeback next year, and growing concern that the federal government might not be able to pay off as much of its debt as projected, have kept long- term interest rates in the bond market from falling below where they were when the Fed began cutting rates in January.

Increasing evidence over the last few months that global economic growth has slowed has pushed up the value of the dollar  the opposite of what normally happens when the Fed is cutting rates  making life harder for American exporters and multinational companies.

The potency of monetary policy is also being diluted by the nature of the slowdown, economists said.

The most powerful brake on the economy right now is not the portion of the economy sensitive to lower interest rates  industries like housing, and consumer spending generally  but the steep decline in spending by businesses on new factories, computers, telecommunications equipment and other capital goods.

Capital spending, especially on technology, is likely to remain weak for some time, even if the Fed continues cutting the short-term interest rates it controls. And until capital spending recovers, economists said, the economy will have trouble returning to the kind of robust growth it enjoyed until late last year.

Both Wall Street and Main Street are often impatient with monetary policy, which has always worked with long and unpredictable lags. It is not unusual for interest rate policy to be impeded by other forces. During the last recession, in the early 1990's, the Fed had to cope with crippling problems among banks and savings and loan institutions.

No one is saying that monetary policy is completely ineffectual. For one thing, economic conditions would probably be a lot worse if the Fed had not been so aggressive in cutting rates this year. And Alan Greenspan, the Fed chairman, told Congress last week that the central bank's rate cuts appeared to have set the stage for economic improvement later in the year. He is scheduled to give further testimony on Tuesday.

Moreover, the economy has other forces working in its favor. The tax cut signed into law last month by President Bush will help as rebate checks begin showing up at most households this summer. Energy prices are falling. Consumers have kept their wallets open.

The consensus among most economists is that the economy should bottom out in the next few months and begin a gradual recovery by the end of the year.

Still, economists said the Fed was clearly getting less bang for the buck than it would hope for with its rate cuts, suggesting that the rebound could be modest and drawn out. 

In the most rapid rate reduction on record, the central bank has cut its benchmark federal funds target rate on overnight loans among banks by 2.75 percentage points this year, to 3.75 percent. Mr. Greenspan has left open the door to at least one more rate cut. But some analysts say the Fed may have to reduce rates further, and keep them low for longer than investors seem to expect.

Monetary policy, said James W. Paulsen, chief investment officer at Wells Capital Management, "may need to be far more aggressive than currently anticipated."

Persistent moves by the Fed to ease monetary policy would be expected to push up stock prices, pull down longer-term interest rates in the bond market and reduce the value of the dollar. All those factors would stimulate economic activity.

This year, however, the overall stock market has remained flat to down by most measures. Long-term interest rates have not fallen. Against some currencies, the dollar has actually shot up in value, inhibiting efforts by companies to offset weakness in their sales at home by selling more of their goods abroad.

"Normally when you have this kind of easing, you would get more help from stocks, bonds and the currency," said William C. Dudley of Goldman, Sachs. "In this case, the stock market's gone down, the dollar has appreciated and bond yields are little changed. What it tells you is that it's not reasonable to expect a big lift from monetary policy."

Stock prices typically rise when interest rates are falling. Rising stock prices would help the economy by making consumers feel wealthier and allowing companies to raise money on favorable terms.

But some analysts say it may be hard to reignite stock prices through lower interest rates because investors are concluding that corporate profits will not fully recover soon.

Competitive pressure to hold down or cut prices is immense, they say, and opportunities for improving profit margins by trimming corporate fat or finding efficiencies in technology could be limited in the next few years. 

Cuts in the short-term rates controlled by the Fed typically help pull down the longer-term rates set in the financial markets. In this case, though, longer-term rates had already fallen substantially last year, when the economy was starting to decelerate. They have not fallen further this year.

To some degree, the bond market seems to be looking beyond the next few months and into next year. And given that long-term rates were relatively low going into this year, interest-sensitive industries  especially housing  have held up quite well as the rest of the economy has slowed. But since those sectors of the economy never weakened much in the first place, they will not be able to play much of a role in leading a comeback.

"The composition of the current downturn has important implications for the economy's growth prospects in the year ahead," Mr. Hale said. "It is doubtful that monetary easing will give a significant boost to residential investment and durable goods consumption because neither sector has experienced a major downturn."

The sector of the economy that most needs help is manufacturing. At this point in a typical business cycle, the Fed's rate cuts could be expected to have pushed down the value of the American currency by reducing the return on investments made in dollars. 

But with the rest of the world slowing  and investors nervous about outbreaks of instability in places like Argentina and Turkey  the dollar has remained a haven even as growth in the United States has ground nearly to a halt. The dollar has appreciated strongly against other currencies, especially the euro, making it harder for American manufacturers to compete in export markets, and reducing profits earned abroad when they are translated back into dollars.


Copyright 2001 The New York Times Company | Privacy Information